Skip to Main content
  • Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe - Evansville

    Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe - Evansville
  • 7766 Fruitwood Lane STE D, Newburgh, IN2130 Stringtown Road, Evansville, IN

Menu

SAUCE AND SEASONING
BEEF
PORK
CHICKEN
GRAB N GO
DELI MEATS AND CHEESES
DELI SALADS

‌

SAUCE AND SEASONING

  • 2 POUND MEAT SEASONING

    $16.49/lb
  • Merkley BBQ Seasoning 32oz

    $11.49/lb
  • Merkley BBQ Seasoning 8oz

    $4.49/lb
  • OFBS Meat Seasoning 8oz

    $7.49/lb
  • Louie S Seasoning Italian Beef Au Jus 3 Oz

    Louie's Seasoning Italian Beef Au Jus is perfect for enhancing your beef dishes with a rich, authentic Italian flavor. This 3 oz packet offers a convenient way to create a delicious Au Jus sauce, adding depth to roasts, gravies, or stews.

    $2.99/lb

BEEF

  • Ground Beef 80/20

    Ground beef with an 80% lean and 20% fat ratio.

    $6.29/lb
  • Ground Beef 80/20 Fresh Bag 5LB

    Bulk 80% lean ground beef packaged in a 5LB bag.

    $29.95/lb
  • 90/10 GROUND BEEF

    90% lean 10% fat ground chuck

    $7.29/lb
  • Beef Femur Bone

    $5.49/lb
  • BEEF LIVER

    $5.49/lb
  • Minute Steak

    Thinly sliced pieces of beef ran through the tenderizer, great for breading or throwing on the grill.

    $9.49/lb
  • Boneless Chuck Roast

    A fattier beef roast that will be very tender and shred when cooked.

    $8.99/lb
  • Rump Roast

    A lean roast that is typically slow cooked.

    $8.49/lb
  • Stew Meat

    Lean beef that is cut into 3/4" cubes, good for stew or beef tips.

    $9.49/lb
  • 3-1 Ground Beef Patties 80/20 5LB

    5# box of 80% frozen patties, 3 per pound (15 per box)

    $30.95/lb
  • 4-1 Ground Beef Patties 80/20 5LB

    5# frozen box of 80% lean patties, 4 per pound (20 per box)

    $30.95/lb
  • 4-1 Ground Beef Patties 90/10 5LB

    5# frozen box of 90% lean patties, 4 per pound (20 per box)

    $38.45/lb
  • 3-1 Ground Beef Patties 90/10 5LB

    5# box of 90% frozen patties, 3 per pound (15 per box)

    $38.45/lb
  • 6-1 Ground Beef Patties 80/20 5LB

    $30.95/lb
  • Ribeye Steak

    An upper 2/3 choice beef steak that has intermuscular marbling and more fat than other steaks. *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $16.90/lb
  • Center Cut Filet

    Center cut piece of the beef tenderloin, the most tender piece on the cow. *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $20.00/lb
  • Sirloin Steak

    A steak that comes from the top butt, is very lean and is best served on the medium- medium rare doneness. *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $11.90/lb
  • NY Strip Steak

    A tender, more lean steak that comes from the short loin located on the back of the animal. Good for any cooking preference since leanness is somewhere between beef tenderloin and ribeye . *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $15.60/lb
  • Bacon Wrapped Filet

    One of the best cuts of beef, comes from the beef tenderloin and is wrapped in bacon. *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $14.50/lb
  • T-Bone Steak

    Comes from the short loin of the cow, will have a T-shaped look and will contain what is known as the NY Strip and sometimes the filet. *These prices are for individual steaks, not per LB. If you want more than 1, go through process and reselect again.*

    $15.75/lb
  • Whole Ribeye Loin

    Let us know how you would like it cut and packaged, can do any size and pack! A whole piece will range from 16-17# each.

    $260.00/lb
  • Whole NY Strip Loin

    Let us know how you would like it cut and packaged, we can do any cut/pack! A whole piece ranges from 15-16# each!

    $250.00/lb
  • Whole Trimmed Beef Tenderloin with Trimmings

    A whole piece of beef tenderloin that we can trim and grind trimmings, as well as cut into whatever size steaks you specify. A whole piece weighs 7-8# each!

    $175.00/lb
  • 80/20 Ground Beef 5LB

    5# frozen box of 80% lean beef packaged in 1# bags.

    $28.95/lb

PORK

  • Smoked Pork Shank

    $4.49/lb
  • Bone In Smoked Pork Chops

    $5.99/lb
  • Pork Cutlets

    $4.99/lb
  • Pork Steak

    $4.49/lb
  • Pork Tenderloin

    $6.99/lb
  • Butterfly Pork Chops

    $7.49/lb
  • Pork Sirloin Roast

    $4.49/lb
  • Pork Sausage Pucks

    $5.49/lb
  • Pork Sausage Piggy Links

    $5.49/lb
  • Pork Patties for Grilling

    $5.49/lb
  • Bone In Pork Chops

    Our center cut pork chops can be cut at any thickness, in our case we have them at 1" and .5" so specify what size you'd like!

    $5.49/lb
  • 5# BOX PORK TENDERLOINS

    $29.95/lb
  • Ground Pork Sausage

    $4.49/lb
  • Lean Ground Pork

    $4.19/lb
  • Sliced Smoked Bacon

    $8.49/lb
  • Bratwurst Links

    $5.49/lb
  • Pork Sausage Box 5LB

    $19.45/lb
  • Merkley Smoked Weiners 16oz

    $8.49/lb
  • Merkley Smoked Pork Sausage Links 16oz

    $6.49/lb
  • Merkley Beef Hotdogs 16oz

    $8.49/lb
  • Merkley Snack Stix 8oz

    $7.49/lb
  • Merkley Jalapeño Snack Stix 8oz

    $7.99/lb
  • Merkley Summer Sausage W/ Cheese

    $9.99/lb
  • Merkley Smoked Brat w/ Jala and Cheese 16oz

    $7.49/lb
  • Whole Pork Butt

    These are great to be cut into pork steaks or cooked slowly for pulled pork. A whole pork butt weighs 8-10# each! Quantity will describe whole pieces, not pounds!

    $28.00/lb
  • Baby Back Ribs

    A whole slab of raw baby back ribs, good for any cookout or barbeque. Quantity is for whole pieces, not pounds!

    $18.00/lb
  • St.Louis Ribs

    Quantity above will be in pieces, not pounds! These raw spare ribs are good for any gathering.

    $18.00/lb

CHICKEN

  • Chicken Thighs

    $5.99/lb
  • Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast 8oz

    $9.49/lb
  • Chicken Tenders

    $5.99/lb
  • Chicken Leg Quarter

    $1.89/lb
  • Jumbo Chicken Wings

    $4.49/lb
  • Frozen Chicken Breast 5oz 5LB

    $32.45/lb
  • Whole Chicken Fryer

    A whole frying chicken, great to cook whole or cut up for fried chicken. This price is for the whole bird, not priced by the pound. Each bird weighs 3-3.5#.

    $11.00/lb

GRAB N GO

  • Great Lakes Michigan Cherry Potato Chips

    Experience a unique snack with Michigan Cherry Potato Chips, where tart cherries meet crisp potatoes in an unexpected twist. Perfect for those who love a blend of sweet and savory in their munchies.

    $4.99/lb
  • Grippo's Potato Chips 8oz

    These BBQ Potato Chips offer a delightful crunch with every bite, making them a perfect snack for your next gathering. Enjoy the smoky, savory flavor that's packed in each chip.

    $4.99/lb
  • Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Sea Salt & Vinegar

    Enjoy the satisfying crunch of Kettle Cooked Potato Chips flavored with the perfect blend of sea salt and vinegar. These chips offer a bold taste and a robust texture that's great for snacking anytime.

    $4.99/lb
  • Great Lakes Kettle Cooked Parmesan Ranch Potato Chips, 8 Oz.

    Enjoy the savory blend of Parmesan and ranch flavors in these kettle-cooked potato chips. Each 8-ounce bag offers a satisfyingly crisp snack with a robust taste.

    $4.99/lb
  • Pickled Jalapeno Potato Chips

    Enjoy a bold twist on a classic snack with these Pickled Jalapeno Potato Chips. Each chip packs a punch of spicy jalapeno flavor, perfect for those who like a little heat.

    $4.99/lb
  • Great Lakes Potato Chip Co., Original Potato Chips

    Experience the classic taste of Great Lakes Potato Chip Co.'s Original Potato Chips, made from locally sourced potatoes and a simple sprinkle of salt. These chips offer a perfect crunch, ideal for any snack time or gathering.

    $4.99/lb
  • Kettle Cooked Buffalo Wing Potato Chips

    Enjoy the bold flavor of buffalo wings in every bite with these kettle cooked potato chips. They offer a perfect crunch in a snack that's hard to put down.

    $4.99/lb
  • Great Lakes, Kettle Cooked Potato Chips, Barbeque

    Enjoy a hearty crunch with Great Lakes Kettle Cooked Potato Chips in Barbeque flavor. They're perfect for adding a smoky, savory twist to your snack time.

    $4.99/lb
  • Smoked Pork Sirloin

    $5.49/lb
  • Pulled Pork 2#

    $14.49/lb
  • Pork N Sauce 2#

    $11.49/lb
  • Chicken N Sauce 2#

    $11.49/lb
  • Smoked Chicken Half

    $6.49/lb
  • Saurkraut

    Sauerkraut is a type of fermented cabbage that's popular in German cuisine. It's tangy and can be used as a topping or a side dish.

    $4.49/lb

DELI MEATS AND CHEESES

  • Boss Hawg Ham Sliced

    $11.49/lb
  • Merkley Pit Ham Sliced

    $9.49/lb
  • Brown Sugar Ham Sliced

    $9.49/lb
  • Golden Legacy Turkey Sliced

    $12.49/lb
  • Cajun Turkey Sliced

    $12.49/lb
  • Merkley Garlic Bologna Sliced

    $6.19/lb
  • Merkley German Bologna Sliced

    $5.99/lb
  • Summer Sausage Sliced

    $10.49/lb
  • Roast Beef Sliced

    $14.49/lb
  • Pepperoni Sliced

    $10.49/lb
  • White American Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Yellow American Cheese Sliced

    $9.49/lb
  • Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sliced

    $12.49/lb
  • Smoked Cheddar Cheese Sliced

    $11.49/lb
  • Sharp Yellow Cheese Sliced

    $12.49/lb
  • Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Sliced

    $12.49/lb
  • Garlic Cheddar Cheese Sliced

    $10.49/lb
  • Square Swiss Cheese Sliced

    $8.99/lb
  • Lacey Baby Swiss Cheese Sliced

    $9.49/lb
  • Troyer Hot Pepper Cheese Sliced

    $9.49/lb
  • Pepper Jack Cheese Sliced

    $7.49/lb
  • Habanero Jalapeno Cheese Sliced

    $13.49/lb
  • Desert Fire Cheese Sliced

    $10.49/lb
  • Smoked Provolone Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Mozzarella Cheese Sliced

    $7.99/lb
  • Muenster Cheese Sliced

    $7.49/lb
  • Brick Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Green Onion Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Colby Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Colby Jack Cheese Sliced

    $8.49/lb
  • Merkley Plain Bologna

    $6.19/lb

DELI SALADS

  • Ham Salad

    $6.49/lb
  • Chicken Salad

    $10.49/lb
  • Red Skin Potato Salad

    $5.99/lb
  • Baked Potato Salad

    $6.49/lb
  • Sour Cream And Cheddar Mac Salad

    $5.49/lb
  • Bowtie Pasta Salad

    $5.49/lb
  • Sun Garden Pasta Salad

    $7.49/lb
  • Pimento Cheese Spread

    $7.49/lb
  • Hot Cheese Spread

    $7.49/lb
  • Oreo Delight

    $3.50/lb
  • Tapioca Pudding

    $6.49/lb
  • Smoked Beans

    $8.49/lb
  • Amish Coleslaw

    $4.49/lb

Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe - Evansville Locations and Hours

2130 Stringtown Road

(812) 423-2465
2130 Stringtown Road, Evansville, IN 47711
Closed • Opens Friday at 9AM
View menu
Facebook logo

7766 Fruitwood Lane STE D

(812) 490-9010
7766 Fruitwood Lane STE D, Newburgh, IN 47630
Closed • Opens Friday at 9AM
View menu
Facebook logo
This site is powered byToast logo
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement