Premium Meats

Delicious beef, pork, poultry, and seafood options.

Deli Cuts

Deli meats, signature salads, and gourmet cheeses.

Contact Us


We offer pick up and delivery for parties.

Rib Eyes at The Old Fashioned Butcher Shop in Evansville, Indiana


Beautiful, Fresh Cuts Everyday

Established in Evansville in 1983, the Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe set out to become a premium melting pot of local flavors, sourcing and selling only the highest quality meats. Ever since then, the Shoppe has become the go-to spot for local customers looking for quality cuts of beef, pork, chicken, turkey, and fish.

But it’s not just meats, they offer a wide variety of hot sides and homemade deli salads so you can leave with a full course. The owners take pride in their product selection; they are passionate about providing customers with an engaging meat shopping experience while delivering premium foods unmatched anywhere else in town.



Nice to Meat You

If you’re looking for quality beef, pork, poultry, and seafood products, then Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe is the place to go. Not only can you pick up a variety of fresh cuts of meat, but we also provide selections from the smoker and deli – things like BBQ pulled pork, beef brisket, and savory smoked turkey. And for those who want pre-sliced deli meats or sausage links for breakfast or lunch, we can save you money as well as offer a much better tasting product than most grocery stores. 


We offer a fantastic selection of steak, roast, ground beef and perfectly aged meat.


We carry ribs, pork chops, bacon, sausage, roasts, and other favorites.


We carry whole fryers, all kinds of chicken parts and turkey too.


Enjoy our fresh seafood selection. Cod loins, salmon, shrimp, and more.

Contact Us

Housemade BBQ

We carry Boss Hawg's BBQ menu. Choose from pork, chicken, and turkey in a variety of flavors!

Deli Meats, Salads, & Cheese

Stock up on deli meats, cheeses, and fresh, homemade salads or order one of our deli trays.

We Provide Fresh Meat Every Day

If high quality and premium meat is what you’re looking for, Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe has exactly what you need. We offer the freshest beef, pork, poultry, seafood, and deli meats to suit any taste.  Come on down to our shop to see our high quality products and learn from our knowledgeable staff.

Scroll to Top

Evansville Shop