Review Us

5/5
Quick service even though it was REALLY busy on their 35th celebration day. All the meat looked GREAT! Burgers and hot dogs tasted delicious along with the seafood. Will definitely come back again.
Kellyann Walker
Kellyann WalkerGoogle Reviews
Staff was beyond excellent. It was my first time in their shoppe. I loved the experience and knowledge the staff gave me. The staff also answered all my silly questions. This shoppe has gained a customer. I will be coming back for all my meat purchases. Thank you again guys!
Cheyanne Frank
Cheyanne FrankGoogle Reviews
They've got a great selection and quality of meats with a variety of seasonings and side dishes offered. The owners and staff treat you like family, and go above and beyond to prepare our orders in advance to minimize contact for my elderly mother. 10/10 recommend.
Gina Perry
Gina PerryGoogle Reviews
We buy all our meat from The Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe. It is the highest quality meat we have found and worth every cent you pay for it. We catch the specials each week and they are great.
Lucy Lou
Lucy LouGoogle Reviews
You get great meats and service from friendly people. The freezer packs are well worth buying. A family owned, local business with good prices for quality products at decent prices; what more can you ask for?
Shelly Brown
Shelly BrownGoogle Reviews

PRODUCT LIST

Seafood

Shopping for seafood at the Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe can be a tasty, unique experience. We offer cod loins, salmon, and fresh shrimp. All the seafood is sold within hours of being prepared, so it is always the freshest and most delicious. Whether you need cod for a favorite recipe or are looking for salmon for an unforgettable dinner, Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe satisfies any taste or craving.

Cod Loins

The loin of cod is the middle third of a cod fillet, and is especially moist and flaky. As with the rest of the fish, cod loin has a sweet, subtle flavor and pearly white flesh and is just at home in a full flavored sauce as it is coated in batter.

Salmon

We ensure every filet is perfectly prepared and served farm-to-table fresh with impeccable presentation.

Shrimp

Nothing is quite like the taste of the shrimp prepared in our Shoppe. You won’t find the same flavors or textures in shrimp from anywhere else.

We Provide Fresh Meat Every Day

Housemade BBQ

Wholesale quantities and pricing available upon request.

OFBS Socials
Tiktok Pinterest Instagram Youtube
Our Products

Evansville Shop

Evansville Facebook
Facebook

Newburgh Shop

Newburgh Facebook
Facebook
  • Business Hours

Monday: Closed

Tuesday – Friday: 9 AM – 5 PM

Saturday: 8 AM – 3 PM

Sunday: Closed

Monday Closed
Tuesday - Friday 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Sunday Closed

Copyright 2023 © Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe. All Rights Reserved. 

Scroll to Top

Evansville Shop

NEWBURGH SHOP

The Old Fashioned Butcher Shop in Evansville, Indiana

We have open Positions In Newburgh

SHIFT HOURS: 

6AM – 6PM TUES-SAT

FOOD PREP | BBQ COOK
FULL TIME | PART TIME
  • Previous restaurant & catering experience
  • Self motivated & able to work independently
  • Knowledgeable prepping & cooking foods
PRODUCTION | SANITATION
PART TIME
  • Previous experience requested
  • Organized, timely & reliable
  • Self motivated & able to work independently
CUSTOMER SERVICE | RETAIL
FULL TIME | PART TIME
  • Previous experience preferred
  • Cashier, Sales, Inventory & Food Prep
  • Organized, timely, & reliable
  • Able to work Saturdays
Join Our Team Today!